Risk 2015: Risk and values

In preparation of the 2015 National Architecture Conference - Risk, Rahul Mehrotra discusses the nuances of risk.

The temporal dimension is very important in order to calibrate the nature of risk. Just as climate change encompasses both slow disasters and quick disasters, so too a career can be wrecked by one building collapse or by the slow erosion of a reputation due to poor work over time.

At the dimension of scale, it is important to consider whether a risk is borne by you alone, or across a community. As an architect, you can egoistically assume all the authorship, but then you also shoulder all the risk. When you become more collaborative, you are also spreading risk. Community building, which is the approach that is very important in my work, is all about spreading risk in a positive sense.

In either case, the question of risk becomes more nuanced when related to values. The moment you nuance your understanding of risk and calibrate it differently, in relation to value judgements, collective endeavour and the temporal scale, it takes on a greater degree of complexity. This then presents positive possibilities, where risks can lead to gains.

In the realm of architecture teaching, which I have been involved in for some time, I realize that the question of risk has also changed radically. The use of interface technology and design processes in education has changed dramatically, and one of its outcomes is that students are becoming less committed.

In one respect students are taking risks, but the consequences of the risks are diminished. As a simple example, when I used to draw by hand using rulers and French curves, changing the design was not a quick task. Every commitment meant a greater risk. With today’s technology, every move is much more reversible and therefore much less of a risk. That has a massive bearing. I would argue that these new technologies allow greater explorations, but at some expense to commitment and to the rewards of risk.



Published online: 30 Apr 2015
Words: Rahul Mehrotra
Images: Courtesy of The Holcim Foundation


Architecture Australia, March 2015

Related topics

More discourse

See all
Render of Baugruppen at WGV, Perth, designed by Spaceagency Architects. A “live project,” it will allow the design and construction of apartments to be initiated by buyers – a participatory process that is unprecedented in the Australian marketplace. Housing Diversity: Opportunities for Transformation

To address contemporary housing challenges, architects will need to take n an “all-of-system” approach to the delivery of the built environment. Shane Murray examines national …

Devaluing care: The issue of unpaid hours Devaluing care: The issue of unpaid hours

Lynda Simmons discusses how the hours spent ‘working’ and ‘caring’ are divided and how that might affect architecture practices.

Bushfire haze over Sydney. ‘We have a responsibility’: architects make carbon neutral pledge

A new initiative has seen a number of Australian architecture practices commit to becoming carbon neutral businesses by the end of 2020.

Aerial photograph of Darwin’s CBD. Ethical and scientifically sound architectural solutions to the climate crisis

Can architecture and construction science influence the regional and global climate crisis and provide credible, scientifically sound and ethical solutions?

Most read

Latest on site